This may be a bit off topic from animation, but I'm just curious to hear all of your opinions. After watching the documentary on George Lucas and his journey to making Star Wars I decided to look more into George Lucas movies. Whenever you think of George Lucas you think of Star Wars and you also think of him being one of the great directors, along side people like Scorsese or Spielberg. But I realized that not many of his movies were great. Yes, American Graffiti and the first Star Wars were great films, but the other films that he directed seems to have very mixed reviews. Directors like Steven Spielberg and Quentin Tarantino seem to consistently bring out great pieces of work, but with George Lucas only about 2-3 films that he directed really comes to mind. Sure, he created one of the greatest franchises ever and he also helped change the film industry with digital editing, but does that make him a great director?
I've also been wondering where the line is drawn between animation and live action. So many films are almost entirely animated, but a few actors on screen make it a "live action" film. Particularly with the new Lion King film--there's literally no live action elements in that film. It should be called the CGI Lion King rather than live action. Just because it's a different kind of animation doesn't mean it's not animated.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Madison that the line has become so blurred, now more than ever. Even looking at Marvel films, people consider it live action yet half the costumes and weapons are done in post production. But what separates Iron Man from the Polar Express? How does a film done in CGI with real actors differentiate from Robert Downey Jr in a green suit?
ReplyDelete